How should a lawyer handle a client's settlement decision?

The appropriate way for a lawyer to handle a client's settlement decision is to communicate the options and provide advice while ultimately allowing the client to make the final decision. This approach emphasizes the attorney's role as a guide and advisor, ensuring that the client is fully informed about the potential consequences of different settlement options. It respects the client's autonomy and decision-making authority over their case, which is a fundamental principle in legal ethics.

By presenting various options and explaining the implications of each, the lawyer allows the client to understand their position and make a decision that aligns with their interests and goals. This method not only upholds the ethical obligation to respect the wishes of the client but also fosters a trusting relationship where the client feels involved and empowered in their legal process.

In contrast, making the decision for the client undermines their autonomy and goes against ethical standards that prioritize client control over their legal choices. Advising against all settlements or presenting only one option restricts the client’s ability to evaluate their circumstances and makes it difficult for them to weigh their options effectively. Thus, providing comprehensive information and respectful guidance is the best practice for handling a client's settlement decision.